December 3, 2020

View: An excessive amount of at stake, all of us must preserve religion in due strategy of legislation



Ultimately, the STF of the UP Police confirmed extra daring than Vikas Dubey had bargained for. His give up in Ujjain was a ploy to pre-empt the UP Police from neutralising him. The early morning skidding of a police jeep and the following occasions culminating in his demise want no recounting. Dubey couldn’t escape the wrath of the identical police power that had benignly allowed him to flourish in rural Kanpur for over 20 years.

However on the night time of July 2, he had damaged the accord and challenged the monopoly over violence of the state police. The last word hegemony of the state and the police to make use of power and violence needed to be restored. His demise is being described as a ‘collateral injury’ by the state police.

Reactions to his ‘encounter’ have been on predictable traces. Probably the most vocal voice is that of a triumphant citizenry that has internalised the Singham-style policing depicted in Bollywood and the ‘thok do’ coverage of the state. One is reminded of the massive public assist for the blinding of criminals in Bhagalpur within the mid-1970s.

There are some who rue the misplaced alternative to query him and unravel his monetary and political tentacles. Old fashioned liberals, who nonetheless imagine that the Basic Rights in our Structure continues to be essential to our nationhood, shake their heads in despair.

Encounters have been the tactic of selection for UP Police for a very long time. When the late VP Singh was UP chief minister, his brother, a Excessive Court docket decide, was killed in an incident by dacoits in April 1982. This was adopted by the Behmai bloodbath by Phulan Devi. In response, UP Police was given the go- forward to eradicate criminals.

Many of those encounters have raised critical questions in regards to the rule of legislation. The killing of suspected Sikh terrorists in Pilibhit in UP in 1991 led to the conviction of 47 police officers. Nonetheless, such setbacks haven’t deterred the police from resorting to this tough and prepared tactic, particularly when the alerts from the corridors of energy have been conducive. A December 2019 tweet by the UP Police declares that 103 criminals have been killed and 1,859 injured in 5,178 police engagements within the final two years. This was in response to a tweet by a former CM, who exhorted the UP Police to ‘take inspiration’ from the Hyderabad Police that had killed 4 alleged rapists in an encounter yesterday. The absence of encounter is equated with Jungle Raj.

A long time of encounters haven’t liberated UP from the clutches of determined criminals. The criminal-contractor-politician nexus with the police thrives regardless of these excessive measures. Not sufficient thought has been given to search for an alternate mannequin to rein within the outlaws.

One attainable mannequin, that has been a hit, is the one executed in Bihar, by Abhayanand as ADGP/DGP. He recognized the highest 20 criminals from every district and with the complete backing of presidency and cooperation of the judiciary launched an efficient prosecution towards them. The end result was that lots of of criminals and outlaws, who used their muscle energy to both win authorities contracts or win native elections bought convicted.

In 2010, 37 accused got capital punishment and 1,875 had been sentenced to life imprisonment. Shahbuddin, Anand Mohan, Prabhunath Singh, Suraj Bhan (all MPs) and Raj Vallabh Yadav and Rajendra Yadav (each MLAs) are examples. Parallely, in all instances the place criminals who had been out on bail dedicated any crime, petitions for cancellation of bail had been filed within the Excessive Court docket. Massive scale cancellation of bail adopted. The majesty of the legislation was strengthened and the police received appreciation.

The prosecution continues to be a weak hyperlink in our legal justice system, a minimum of in UP. Madhya Pradesh has taken steps to reverse this development. Prosecution is essential as session instances are within the palms of presidency counsels who are sometimes appointed on extraneous concerns and are not often held to account for the failure of the prosecution. The falling requirements of investigation and the more and more low precedence given to supervision of investigation by senior officers are properly established.

The modifications led to within the prosecution construction by the Prison Process Code of 1973 have created two silos of investigation and prosecution. The outcomes have been disappointing and the sufferer is the religion of the citizenry within the efficacy of the Prison Justice System to ship justice. Legislation takes its course. However justice stays elusive.

Condoning and endorsing of disproportionate use of power, despite the fact that the legal deserves no mercy, reinforces such behavioural traits amongst police leaders and the power, and lessens respect for the legislation amongst residents.

Our dedication to the due course of and process established by legislation can’t be lowered to rhetoric. It’s a fundamental basis of our democracy. It can’t be allowed to change into collateral injury. An excessive amount of is at stake.


(The writer is former DGP, UP)